Every search result page is a competition. When another website consistently outranks yours, it is doing something that search engines reward, whether that is stronger content, better backlinks, or a faster, cleaner technical setup. An SEO competitor analysis helps you uncover those advantages and build a strategy to surpass them. Rather than guessing, you base decisions on real evidence from the websites you are competing against. In this guide, we will walk through a practical, step-by-step example of how to do SEO competitor analysis for a fictional business so you can apply the same process to your own site.
How AAMAX.CO Supports Competitor-Driven SEO Strategies
Competitor research can be time-consuming and requires experience to interpret correctly. AAMAX.CO is a full-service digital marketing company offering web development, digital marketing, and SEO services worldwide. Their specialists conduct thorough competitor audits, identify keyword and content gaps, analyze backlink profiles, and translate findings into prioritized roadmaps. Because they handle both strategy and execution, businesses working with them can move from insights to implementation quickly, closing the gap with competitors and building sustainable ranking advantages.
Our Example Scenario
Imagine a company called GreenLeaf Planters, an online store selling self-watering indoor planters. They rank on page two for their most important keywords and want to understand why three competitors consistently dominate page one. We will follow GreenLeaf through each stage of the analysis to show how the process works in practice.
Step 1: Identify Your True Search Competitors
Your search competitors are not always your business competitors. They are the sites ranking for the keywords you want. GreenLeaf starts by listing ten priority keywords such as "self-watering planters," "best planters for indoor plants," and "low-maintenance plant pots." They search each term and record which domains appear repeatedly in the top ten. Three domains stand out: a large home decor retailer, a niche planter brand, and a gardening blog with affiliate content. These become the focus of the analysis. SEO tools like Ahrefs, Semrush, or Similarweb can speed this up by showing domains with the greatest keyword overlap.
Step 2: Conduct a Keyword Gap Analysis
Next, GreenLeaf compares its keyword rankings against those of the three competitors. A keyword gap tool shows terms competitors rank for that GreenLeaf does not. The findings are revealing. The gardening blog ranks for dozens of informational queries such as "how often to water snake plants" and "why are my plant leaves turning yellow." The niche brand ranks for product-specific terms like "large self-watering planter for fiddle leaf fig." GreenLeaf realizes it has focused almost entirely on broad commercial keywords and ignored both informational and long-tail product searches that feed buyers into the funnel.
Step 3: Analyze Top-Ranking Content
Keywords tell you what to target, but content analysis tells you how to win. GreenLeaf reviews the top-ranking pages for its primary keywords and notes their format, length, depth, and structure. The winning category page from the niche brand includes a buying guide, comparison table, customer reviews, and an FAQ section. GreenLeaf's equivalent page is simply a product grid with a short sentence of copy. The competitor's blog posts include original photos, step-by-step instructions, and expert tips. This comparison shows that search engines and users favor comprehensive, helpful pages that fully satisfy intent.
Step 4: Evaluate Backlink Profiles
Backlinks remain a powerful ranking signal. GreenLeaf uses a backlink tool to review each competitor's referring domains. The home decor retailer has thousands of links from news outlets and lifestyle magazines. The niche brand has earned links from product roundups, interior design blogs, and a popular sustainability publication. The gardening blog attracts links from forums and educational sites because of its helpful guides. GreenLeaf, by contrast, has only a handful of directory links. The team lists realistic opportunities: pitching product roundup writers, creating a linkable plant care resource, and collaborating with interior design influencers.
Step 5: Review Technical SEO Factors
Technical issues can quietly hold a site back. GreenLeaf runs its site and each competitor through performance and crawling tools. The competitors load in under two seconds on mobile, while GreenLeaf takes more than five seconds because of uncompressed images and heavy scripts. Competitors also use structured data for products and reviews, which earns rich results with star ratings in search. GreenLeaf has duplicate content issues from filtered category URLs. These discoveries become quick wins that can be fixed before tackling larger content projects.
Step 6: Examine On-Page Optimization and User Experience
GreenLeaf then compares title tags, meta descriptions, headings, internal linking, and page layouts. Competitor titles include clear benefits and modifiers such as "best" or "for beginners," which improve click-through rates. Their pages feature intuitive navigation, prominent trust badges, and helpful internal links to related guides. Small on-page improvements like rewriting titles and adding contextual links can create meaningful ranking and conversion gains.
Step 7: Turn Findings Into an Action Plan
Analysis only matters if it leads to action. GreenLeaf prioritizes tasks by impact and effort. First, fix site speed, add product schema, and resolve duplicate URLs. Second, expand category pages with buying guides and FAQs. Third, launch a plant care content hub targeting informational keywords from the gap analysis. Fourth, begin a steady outreach campaign to earn quality backlinks. Each task is assigned an owner and a timeline, and rankings are tracked monthly. Businesses that lack in-house expertise often rely on professional SEO services to execute plans like this efficiently.
Step 8: Monitor and Repeat
Competitor landscapes shift constantly. New players enter, algorithms change, and rivals update their content. GreenLeaf schedules a quarterly competitor review to track changes in keyword share, new backlinks, and content launches. With AI-driven search experiences becoming more common, they also monitor how competitors appear in AI-generated answers, an area where GEO services are becoming increasingly valuable.
Conclusion
Doing an SEO competitor analysis follows a clear process: identify search competitors, find keyword gaps, study top content, evaluate backlinks, audit technical performance, compare on-page elements, and convert insights into a prioritized plan. As the GreenLeaf example shows, the answers to why competitors outrank you are usually visible once you know where to look. Consistently applying these insights allows any business to close the gap and eventually claim the top positions for itself.
Want to publish a guest post on aamconsultants.org?
Place an order for a guest post or link insertion today.